Wittgenstein on meaning and use james conant, university of pittsburgh g. Philosophy of the information society the website of the. I mentioned the philosophical investigation because it is the tractatus and philosophical investigations because they are the most wellknown representatives of the early and late wittgenstein respectively. Wittgensteins lasting significance, edited by max kolbel and. Paul gordon horwich is a british analytic philosopher at new york university, noted for his contributions to philosophy of science, philosophy of physics, the philosophy of language especially truth and meaning and the interpretation of wittgensteins later philosophy. Wittgensteins critique of the mechanical thesis or the man behind the machine discussions on the foundation of mathematics chess as a formal mathematical model turing chess as a linguistic model wittgenstein chess and gaming theory in the inception of early digital computers and in ai or chess playing machine as a sign of. And that mystery has been the virtual absence of interest in the work of wittgenstein. Critical notice wittgensteins metaphilosophy paul horwich. The oxford handbook of wittgenstein, 2011, 824 pages. Review of wittgensteins metaphilosophy by paul horwich. This handbook is the place to look for a full understanding of wittgenstein s special importance to modern philosophy. Heidegger, holzwege1 the most fundamental divide among interpreters of wittgenstein lies, for me, between. Rortys wittgenstein chapter 8 wittgensteins philosophical.
The centrality of wittgensteins metaphilosophy and its susceptibility to rigorous articulation and rational support are admittedly controversial assumptions, but they are vindicated here not just textually, but by the power and plausibility of the philosophy that results from them. First one might note that putting meta in front of any word should be suspect. A new understanding of the work of a great modern thinker. This handbook is the place to look for a full understanding of wittgensteins special importance to modern philosophy. In the tractatus logicophilosophicus 1921, wittgenstein claims that thought involves logical pictures of facts or states of affairs, expressed through a proposition, that is, a single idea asserted about the world through language. Sep 21, 2015 so wittgenstein s metaphilosophy is actually more thoroughgoingly therapeutic than in horwich s interpretation. Wittgenstein s relation to other founders of analytic philosophy such as gottlob frege, bertrand russell, and g. Wittgensteins two famous books are both concerned with meaning and the nature of language. Ludwig wittgenstein s notebooks 19141916 contains his philosophical diary, kept during two of the years in which he was developing the philosophical position formulated in the tractatus logicophilosophicus. For anyone reading or interested in the horwichs book, this debate is insightful. Wittgensteins insights into the workings of language are his main tool to. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy ebook written by paul horwich. The powerlessness of will a theme in wittgensteins early.
Buy wittgensteins metaphilosophy by horwich, paul isbn. The new wittgenstein offers a major reevaluation of wittgenstein s thinking. On this reading, wittgenstein s criticism foreshadows some of the most promising contemporary work on connectionist models of neural functioning. Full text of wittgensteins 193233 lectures on philosophy. A theme in wittgenstein s early philosophy lars hertzberg i. In this provocative and very wellwritten book, paul horwich argues that wittgensteins most important insight is that expressed by his famous remark that philosophy is a battle against the bewitchment of our intelligence by means of language wittgenstein 1973. Hacker anthony kenny has, over the last half a century, been one of the leading wittgenstein scholars in the world, and one of the pioneers in applying wittgensteins ideas and methods to novel domains and problems. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy by paul horwich 201212. In the preface to his fine book, paul horwich deplores the polar split that he sees in academic philosophy today between most philosophers, who dont care about wittgenstein, and the wittgensteinian minority, who dont care about much else, and are engaged in feuds with one other that no one else cares about p. Paul horwich is a professor of philosophy at new york university.
A probing exploration of the true nature of philosophy. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read wittgensteins metaphilosophy. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy, oxford university press 225 pages. Wittgensteins comments on the texts of weyl, hilbert skolem and hardy see also below, and references that he makes in various letters throughout the 1930s and 1940s, are part of a continuous development, and therefore important to an accurate understanding of wittgensteins philosophy of. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy by paul horwich books on. Wittgensteins relation to other founders of analytic philosophy such as gottlob frege, bertrand russell, and g. Ludwig wittgenstein 18891951 issue 87 philosophy now. Jan 01, 2012 however, horwich does a very good job of developing a unified metaphilosophy that can be found in wittgenstein s early and later works. Each essay in this collection explores a key concept involved in wittgenstein s thinking, relating it to his understanding of philosophy, and outlining the arguments. Wittgensteins lectures, 1932 35, edited by alice ambrose, publ. Mar 03, 20 paul horwich is a professor of philosophy at new york university. Sep 25, 2016 ludwig wittgenstein is a philosopher s philosopher. Moore famously in the context of proposing to formulate a refution of philosophical skepticism concerning the existence of the external world pointed to his hand in a welllit lecture hall and uttered the sentence i know this is a hand.
Thus, it appears, following horwich, that the elimination of philosophical pseudoproblems is the key to wittgenstein s metaphilosophy. This metaphilosophy is seen as the unfolding of certain views throughout wittgensteins life, culminating in the first part of the philosophical investigations. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy paul horwich download. Now for some comments on horwich s wittgenstein s metaphilosophy. Thiselton even distinguishes a middle period in wittgensteins work in a. He is the author of several books, including reflections on meaning, truthmeaningreality, and most recently, wittgensteins metaphilosophy. Horwich dismisses the contradictory passages found in the later sections of the investigations as this is one of the many books which exist to tell us lucky people what wittgenstein.
Wittgensteins characterisation of the inconsistency. I mentioned the philosophical investigation because it is the tractatus and philosophical investigations because they are the most wellknown representatives of the early and late wittgenstein respectively, gabriel aug 26 15 at 17. Peter hacker explains wittgenstein s metaphilosophical views, talks about the mind, and. If this is correct, the end of philosophical theories will follow automatically when we no longer have anything to theorize about. Full text of wittgenstein s 193233 lectures on philosophy. In the preface to his fine book, paul horwich deplores the polar split that he sees in academic philosophy today between most philosophers, who dont care about wittgenstein, and the wittgensteinian minority, who dont care about much else, and are engaged in feuds. This book develops an interpretation of ludwig wittgensteins later writings in particular, his philosophical investigations that differs in. Wittgenstein on context and philosophical pictures springerlink. Original and controversial work from a distinguished expert on the subject.
Wittgenstein s lectures, 1932 35, edited by alice ambrose, publ. Scholarly interest is quickening in this other dimension to wittgensteins work, and malcolms book comes opportunely. Apart from the details of wittgensteins philosophical positions in these two works, we will consider the continuity of his philosophy and his views on ethics. Wittgenstein s metaphilosophy by paul horwich, 9780199661121, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Wittgenstein on context and philosophical pictures. Buy wittgenstein s metaphilosophy by horwich, paul isbn. Now for some comments on horwichs wittgensteins metaphilosophy. Ludwig wittgensteins notebooks 19141916 contains his philosophical diary, kept during two of the years in which he was developing the philosophical position formulated in the tractatus logicophilosophicus.
In this paper, i will investigate wittgensteins idea about the contextsensitivity of utterance. To see the connection between the members of a sequence representing a real num1 the question in what sense wittgenstein characterizes real numbers as laws is thoroughly discussed in the. Wittgenstein on aspectperception, logic, and mathematics juliet floyd wittgensteins remarks invoking aspectperception mirror his overall development as a philosopher. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy by paul horwich, 9780199661121, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Wittgenstein, ludwig 1889, austrian philosopher, was born in vienna and.
Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Furthermore, the paper also reveals that the rendition by the aforementioned scholars that wittgenstein calls for the. Peter hacker explains wittgensteins metaphilosophical views, talks about the. Thus, it appears, following horwich, that the elimination of philosophical pseudoproblems is the key to wittgensteins metaphilosophy. According to wittgensteins antitheoretical, deflationary view of philosophy, traditional or theoretical philosophy. Resolute readings are explained and defended in a long reply to williams and. This is what wittgenstein wrote about his work after 1929 for chambers encyclopedia, new ed. Wittgenstein s complex and demanding work challenges much that is taken for granted in philosophical thinking as well as in the theorizing of art, theology, science and culture. Pdf horwich gives a fine analysis of wittgenstein w and is a leading w scholar, but in my view they all fall short of a full appreciation, as i. Wittgenstein on logical form and the nature of philosophy. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy by paul horwich oxford university press, 2012, 248 pp. Paul horwich, oxford university press, oxford, 2012, pp. Horwich does not mention this inevitable closing down of philosophy.
The plausibility of wittgensteins metaphilosophy timothy. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy paul horwich he argues that it is wittgensteins radically antitheoretical metaphilosophyand not as assumed by most other commentators his identification of the meaning of a word with its usethat lies at the foundation of his discussions of specific issues concerning language, the mind, mathematics, knowledge, art, and religion. If one does not understand w and preferably searle also. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy oxford university press, 2012. This metaphilosophy is seen as the unfolding of certain views throughout wittgenstein s life, culminating in the first part of the philosophical investigations. This this book is a stellar collection of essays that present a significantly different portrait of. While i do not want overly to geneticize the philosophical terrain connected with aspectperception, i do. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy zurich open repository and archive.
After a few remarks about the constructive nature of wittgensteins preoccupation with pictures section, i consider the earliest passage in his writing invoking puzzlepictures section %, then consider. On this reading, wittgensteins criticism foreshadows some of the most promising contemporary work on connectionist models of neural functioning. Whether or not this picture is entirely fair either to. Wittgensteinians or antiwittgensteinians will find it interesting. It is the idea that there is a big gap between understanding a sentence in the sense of knowing the idioms and discerning the grammar in it, and what is said by using it in a particular context. The first is taken from a chapter on wittgensteins childhood and schooldays, while the second sums up a piece about his life as a whole. The first is taken from a chapter on wittgenstein s childhood and schooldays, while the second sums up a piece about his life as a whole. Curry in a discipline that has sometimes seemed inexhaustibly voracious in its appetite for new philosophical delicacies, there has long or so it has seemed to me been a mystery. Wittgensteins styles of thinking 174 notes 189 11 prolegomenon to a pedagogy of self 192. The powerlessness of will a theme in wittgensteins. I was fortunate to have met tony when i was a junior. We will not be discussing any of wittgensteins works after the philosophical investigations, including on certainty nor his several remarks and writings on the philosophy of psychology.
To show the fly the way out of the flybottle pi 309 had it been a novel paul horwich would already have given the plot away in the very first lines of the first. A theme in wittgensteins early philosophy lars hertzberg i. The development of wittgensteins philosophy of psychology p. Wittgensteins metaphilosophy the philosophical quarterly.
1009 553 697 222 507 1415 925 1155 1313 59 1424 1001 1146 730 1001 300 482 1436 570 1536 1458 512 728 1064 1016 255 1311 500 1113 1355 549 38 151 1405 1 343 170 1084 72 1003 109